The Limits of Magical Thinking

If you’ve read my story you already know that I grew up Mormon.  My parents were Mormons.  My dad’s parents were Mormons.  Their parents before them were Mormons.  As a matter of fact, my family are Mormons since 1836.  The community I grew up in was, per capita, more Mormon than Salt Lake City.  Oh, there were a couple of Catholic churches in town, and a Baptist church.  I even knew a couple of kids in my school that attended them.  But they were part of a different and scary world.  The way I was raised seemed like the most normal, natural thing in the world.

One of the tenants of the faith is personal revelation through the Holy Ghost.  If you ask God in faith, He will let you know that the Mormon church is the true, restored church founded by Jesus Christ.  You will know this because, well, you’ll feel it.

The first year of so of my recovery had very much the same spiritual flavor of being a faithful Mormon.  No doubt that God, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, lived, and that He cared for me personally.  There was no spiritual ambiguity or doubt on my part.  There was simply a blind, and rather naive willingness, perhaps even an eagerness, to suspend disbelief and live in a world of certainty and personal knowledge of a God that was personal to me.

Over the last two and a half or three years I’ve wrestled mightily with the God Concept of AA.  But I’m beginning to understand that I came by my faithlessness honestly.  It is left over from a different time.  It is left over from growing up Mormon and being gay.

How could a 14-year-old boy be an abomination to God?  I was faithful to the church in every other way, but I knew I had to hide my same-sex attraction.  It was immoral.  They taught me that it was a mortal sin; the kind that God wouldn’t forgive.  It took some punishment and it took getting to know myself and my true feelings better, and it took finding some of the glaring fallacies in the Mormon scriptures that contradict empirical reality, for me to reject the church, and to reject God.

Whatever you want to call my Mormon baggage, I haul it in with me to Alcoholics Anonymous and I use it as a kind of yard stick for measuring bullshit.

I don’t think that I can comfortably practice the program if a deity is involved.  Some more generic, etherial “higher power” sounds nice enough, but my impulse to uncover truth instead of accepting and following blindly, eventually brings me to a place that the only higher power I have any kind of faith in at all is the steps, and the fellowship of some close friends in AA.

I guess that basically makes me a heretic.  At least it does around here.  So I need to find a way to separate the Mormon Baggage from the Program of Recovery, just to put my mind more at ease.  Just so I’m not constantly on the lookout for fraud and rejection.

Fortunately I’ve found some online groups recently who honor their Mormon traditions, but don’t believe a word they say.  Maybe if I keep learning about this and taking a look at my part of what unfolded in my early Mormon life, I’ll be able to put this to rest and be able to live happily in the rooms of AA again.

Tags: , , ,

  1. Chris, your thinking is so fresh and at times, vulnerable. It makes me love you more for sharing parts of your true self with us. Much love to you.

    Reply

  2. my experience was similar, but didn’t leave me distrusting my skepticism and doubt – i have found a god who is okay with it, me kicking at the tires, testing the metal and throwing away the chaff. i’m not sure how i lucked out on that, but it works for me. the way i explained it a few weeks ago at a meeting was that i was able to divorce god from the church – the distortions and dogma i was given as a girl weren’t from god – but were from patriarchal men who didn’t speak for him, but only said they did. i was able somehow to see god just as ticked off and as sad by their misrepresentation of him as i was – so we’re on the same team still somehow. i am so glad that you have found those online groups – i would just encourage you to know that that god of the 14 year old tex was just as wounded by their judgements of you as you were. i know he’s on your side and pulling for you my friend.

    Reply

    1. I’ve come to think of it like this, Heidi. IF (if) there is a God, a “Creator of the Universe” in whose image we are created, (s)he seems to have created some people with the ability to experience faith and to feel the nearness of his/her presence. Others of us were created without it. (and to us he gave irony. ;-) )

      Reply

  3. I don’t believe in God but recently I came to redefine what it meant to me not to believe in God. I lost my wallet on a path in the woods and automatically I searched in my heart for that metaphysical daddy who’d come help me. It was so funny. I did find the wallet through sheer diligence but then when I was full of thankfulness I searched again for that metaphysical daddy who would care and tell me, ‘good job.’

    Reply

    1. You are already your own metaphysical daddy, when you choose to be. We all are. If we take the dogma in the AA book at face value it says that we have to look for God within ourselves, because it is there that “He” is found. Congratulations on finding your wallet. I hope you know what a good job you did.

      Reply

  4. Two and a half years sober and I find myself so fucked off about the conception of god that I got sober with that I can’t live joyfully. In all likelihood I just haven’t given myself enough time to heal or something but at the moment it seems like the “power” that got me sober was an episode of magical thinking from which I have been medically released.

    Reply

    1. I think we make it too hard to believe. All we have to do is be willing. And to practice gratitude. I haven’t found one person who has been stretched to the limits of their belief like I have. Ever since Bob was killed, I’ve lost first my alimony, then my ability to work, and now my house is going into foreclosure. I’ve had to put one dog down and soon my beloved Klausy (cat) will have to be euthanized. I’ve also lost my boyfriend, had two suicide attempts and now I’m living on pure faith with no income, no place to go and no one to help me with the repairs on my house. And yet I know God is here, and that He has a plan. Period. If not for God, I wouldn’t be sober today. My first sincere prayer: “God help me”, was answered and ever since then I have believed. I wouldn’t be here were it not for that still small voice that keeps me going. Everyone else–as far as I can see–has luxury problems.

      Reply

      1. wow millison – there are no words, feeling your loss as i read your words.

        one of my absolute favorite authors is annie lamott – and her meeting god story in “traveling mercies” is the best. she has a new book coming out soon called “help, thanks, wow” – really the only 3 prayers we need. she is my high priestess – such a simple, cynical, jaded faith – but she is so rich with it. can’t give higher recommendation to her writing.

        and chris- irony and a sense of humor – you are flush with it – and i do agree that it is a gift. you will really love annie too.

        Reply

    2. I totally understand.

      Reply

get userping